Review By: ChelanID - State: Alabama

Vendor: MagicFakes


I found MagicFakes on reddit as I was searching for a reputable vendor after being scammed by It looked like they had recently had a promo that offered two free ID's in exchange for a review, which sounded almost too good to be true, but I decided to reach out anyways.

Communication: 10/10

I contacted them first through email (took them some hours to respond) and then through Wickr Pro, where they responded almost immediately always. Their communication was very clear, very straightforward, very polite, and very informative.

Cost: 10/10

They apologized and told me that their promo was done, but were super kind and agreed to offer me a 50% off discount. I am so appreciative! The IDs I received were so unbelievably accurate and exceeded any of my expectations, and are clearly worth more than the $40 that I paid.

Shipping: 10/10

Arrived in two weeks! Discreet packaging.

signature: 10/10

Looks good but has a little bit of bleeding, but that can only be noticed when my eyes are inches away. I doubt anyone will notice.


template: 10/10

Everything is the exact same, everywhere. The fonts are identical, as are the colors, barcode and small text placement.

photoshop: 10/10

I'm currently looking at my fake ID and my U21 ID side by side. The fake replicates the yellow, washed-out effect my real ID photo has, which is from the strong flash at the DMV. The images are cropped the same. This is perhaps not an error of MagicFakes but one of mine: If you're going to get a Washington ID, make the blue background a deep "Carolina blue" rather than a sky/light blue so that it matches the real ID better. Everything else looks perfect.

holograms/OVI: 10/10

Great! Very crisp, and identical placement as my U21 ID.

uv: 8/10

I give this an 8 because I haven't tested the UV. However judging by the clear attention to detail and care that they have given the rest of the ID, I'm confident that the UV would show up great.

scanning: 10/10

I've only had the opportunity to test my ID out with iPhone scanning apps, but they have all passed. I've even made sure the apps themselves work by scanning my U21 ID, and they've also successfully identified that one as underage.

conclusion: 10/10

I'm super happy with the whole experience that I've had purchasing my ID from MagicFakes. I think they're a newer vendor, so you'll get more affordable prices with great quality IDs that can compare to what more well known but expensive vendors might offer.